• Home
  • About
  • May: Mental Health Awareness Month 2022
  • Events
    • Coffee & Discussion >
      • Past C&D Minutes >
        • September 2020 C&D
        • July 2020 C&D
        • May 2020 C&D
        • January 2020 C&D
        • November 2019 C&D
        • July 2019 C&D
        • May 2019 C&D
        • March 2019 C&D
        • February 2019 C&D
        • November 2018 C&D
    • Symposia
  • Newsletters
    • Most Recent Newsletter
    • Archive of Past Newsletters >
      • May 12th, 2022 Newsletter
      • April 28th, 2022 Newsletter
      • April 14th, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 31st, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 17th, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 3rd, 2022 Newsletter
      • February 17th, 2022 Newsletter
      • February 3rd, 2022 Newsletter
      • January 20th, 2022 Newsletter
      • January 6th, 2022 Newsletter
      • December 9th, 2021 Newsletter
      • November 23rd, 2021 Newsletter
      • November 11th, 2021 Newsletter
      • October 28th, 2021 Newsletter
      • October 14th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 30th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 16th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 2nd, 2021 Newsletter
      • August 19th, 2021 Newsletter
      • August 5th, 2021 Newsletter
      • July 22nd, 2021 Newsletter
      • May 17th, 2021 Newsletter
      • April 15th, 2021 Newsletter
      • April 1st, 2021 Newsletter
      • March 4th, 2021 Newsletter
      • February 16th, 2021 Newsletter
      • January 15th, 2021 Newsletter
      • December 17th, 2020 Newsletter
      • November 12, 2020 Newsletter
      • October 29, 2020 Newsletter
      • September 29, 2020 Newsletter
      • August 21, 2020 Newsletter
      • August 6, 2020 Newsletter
      • July 20, 2020 Newsletter
      • July 6, 2020 Newsletter
      • June 25, 2020 Newsletter
      • June 1, 2020 Newsletter
  • COVID-19 Information
    • Supporting Your Health and Well-being
    • Engaging with Nature at Home
  • Recent Research
    • ​Students & Staff Reading Recent Research Blog
  • Nature Near You
  • Current Projects
    • Education Working Group
    • Illinois NatureRx Working Group
  • Get Involved
NCH2
  • Home
  • About
  • May: Mental Health Awareness Month 2022
  • Events
    • Coffee & Discussion >
      • Past C&D Minutes >
        • September 2020 C&D
        • July 2020 C&D
        • May 2020 C&D
        • January 2020 C&D
        • November 2019 C&D
        • July 2019 C&D
        • May 2019 C&D
        • March 2019 C&D
        • February 2019 C&D
        • November 2018 C&D
    • Symposia
  • Newsletters
    • Most Recent Newsletter
    • Archive of Past Newsletters >
      • May 12th, 2022 Newsletter
      • April 28th, 2022 Newsletter
      • April 14th, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 31st, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 17th, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 3rd, 2022 Newsletter
      • February 17th, 2022 Newsletter
      • February 3rd, 2022 Newsletter
      • January 20th, 2022 Newsletter
      • January 6th, 2022 Newsletter
      • December 9th, 2021 Newsletter
      • November 23rd, 2021 Newsletter
      • November 11th, 2021 Newsletter
      • October 28th, 2021 Newsletter
      • October 14th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 30th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 16th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 2nd, 2021 Newsletter
      • August 19th, 2021 Newsletter
      • August 5th, 2021 Newsletter
      • July 22nd, 2021 Newsletter
      • May 17th, 2021 Newsletter
      • April 15th, 2021 Newsletter
      • April 1st, 2021 Newsletter
      • March 4th, 2021 Newsletter
      • February 16th, 2021 Newsletter
      • January 15th, 2021 Newsletter
      • December 17th, 2020 Newsletter
      • November 12, 2020 Newsletter
      • October 29, 2020 Newsletter
      • September 29, 2020 Newsletter
      • August 21, 2020 Newsletter
      • August 6, 2020 Newsletter
      • July 20, 2020 Newsletter
      • July 6, 2020 Newsletter
      • June 25, 2020 Newsletter
      • June 1, 2020 Newsletter
  • COVID-19 Information
    • Supporting Your Health and Well-being
    • Engaging with Nature at Home
  • Recent Research
    • ​Students & Staff Reading Recent Research Blog
  • Nature Near You
  • Current Projects
    • Education Working Group
    • Illinois NatureRx Working Group
  • Get Involved

​Students & Staff Reading Recent Research Blog

Can Simulated Nature Support Mental Health? Comparing Short, Single-Doses of 360-Degree Nature Videos in Virtual Reality With the Outdoors.

8/5/2021

0 Comments

 
Picture
Author: Arseniy Minasov
About the Author: Arseniy Minasov is the Research Coordinator at Northwestern’s Department of Anthropology (Dr. Horton Research Group): Health Benefits of Nature. He graduated from Northwestern in 2018 with a B.A. in Biological Anthropology. He studies technology, gaming, and the intersection of nature-based interventions with technology and medicine, while also enjoying competitive gaming and triathlons.

​Don’t Count VR Out of Providing the Benefits of Nature.
Virtual Reality (VR), one of the newest and most powerful technological advancements, may help connect the realms of technology and psychology. VR, used in fields of both medicine and entertainment, is a simulated environment that displaces the user through visual and auditory stimuli into another environment.

With the dual aspects of increased realism and escapism, VR may offer a replacement for visual and auditory stimulation when it comes to simulating real-world psychological benefits, such as exposure to nature and open space/green space.  A VR intervention would, expectedly, be weaker than a real exposure to nature, but those for whom a real-life encounter is impossible may benefit from the virtual experience.


In a 2020 study, researchers at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign sought to understand where along the spectrum of “no physical exposure to nature” to “extensive exposure to nature” VR lies. Participants indicated their “nature preferences” using beauty-and-disgust surveys. Then, in the trial, participants were randomly assigned to sit in one of three places:  (A) facing a white wall, (B) outdoors in nature, or (C) indoors with a VR representation of the same nature space as group B. 

Researchers measured the mood, restorativeness, and skin conductivity levels (SCL) of each participant. Overall, the study found that VR can simulate nature to some extent – with a noticeable difference between no-nature and VR when it came to mood – but VR does not come close to the real-nature intervention.

The study appears to show that VR cannot simulate nature to the extent that would be beneficial on a widespread, unconditional basis.  There are, however, several limitations in the study that merit additional attention. 

First, the VR technology used in the study was from 2015 and found on a Samsung smartphone – not a stand-alone or PC-compatible native VR headset. The differences in quality between those are stark, and despite dramatic advances in a phone’s VR potential in recent years, it is not nearly as powerful as some higher-end VR machines now available. 

Second, the study itself mentions several of its own limitations, such as the fact that its college-student cohort was not ideal for observing changes in psychological variables. (These limitations ring true to our own studies at Northwestern University with actual nature exposure as well.) Nevertheless, with VR still in its relative technological infancy, we should not discredit or discount the idea of having these technological marvels in our own homes and potentially in hospitals to give people who need nature access the possibility of receiving it. 

- Arseniy Minasov
​

Source Article: ​Browning, M., K. J. Mimnaugh, C. J. van Riper, H. K. Laurent and S. M. LaValle (2019). "Can Simulated Nature Support Mental Health? Comparing Short, Single-Doses of 360-Degree Nature Videos in Virtual Reality With the Outdoors." Frontiers in Psychology 10: 2667. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32010003

0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

Home
About
Events
Upcoming
Symposia
Coffee & Discussion
​In The Community

Newsletters
​Most Recent Newsletter 
​Archive of past newsletters
COVID-19 Information
Supporting Your Health and Wellbeing
Engaging with Nature at Home
Recent Research
Nature Near You
Current Projects
Education
Illinois NatureRx
Get Involved
DISCLAIMER: All information, content, and material on this website is for informational purposes only. This information should not replace a medical consultation or treatment plan given by a qualified healthcare provider. ​
Proudly powered by Weebly
  • Home
  • About
  • May: Mental Health Awareness Month 2022
  • Events
    • Coffee & Discussion >
      • Past C&D Minutes >
        • September 2020 C&D
        • July 2020 C&D
        • May 2020 C&D
        • January 2020 C&D
        • November 2019 C&D
        • July 2019 C&D
        • May 2019 C&D
        • March 2019 C&D
        • February 2019 C&D
        • November 2018 C&D
    • Symposia
  • Newsletters
    • Most Recent Newsletter
    • Archive of Past Newsletters >
      • May 12th, 2022 Newsletter
      • April 28th, 2022 Newsletter
      • April 14th, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 31st, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 17th, 2022 Newsletter
      • March 3rd, 2022 Newsletter
      • February 17th, 2022 Newsletter
      • February 3rd, 2022 Newsletter
      • January 20th, 2022 Newsletter
      • January 6th, 2022 Newsletter
      • December 9th, 2021 Newsletter
      • November 23rd, 2021 Newsletter
      • November 11th, 2021 Newsletter
      • October 28th, 2021 Newsletter
      • October 14th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 30th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 16th, 2021 Newsletter
      • September 2nd, 2021 Newsletter
      • August 19th, 2021 Newsletter
      • August 5th, 2021 Newsletter
      • July 22nd, 2021 Newsletter
      • May 17th, 2021 Newsletter
      • April 15th, 2021 Newsletter
      • April 1st, 2021 Newsletter
      • March 4th, 2021 Newsletter
      • February 16th, 2021 Newsletter
      • January 15th, 2021 Newsletter
      • December 17th, 2020 Newsletter
      • November 12, 2020 Newsletter
      • October 29, 2020 Newsletter
      • September 29, 2020 Newsletter
      • August 21, 2020 Newsletter
      • August 6, 2020 Newsletter
      • July 20, 2020 Newsletter
      • July 6, 2020 Newsletter
      • June 25, 2020 Newsletter
      • June 1, 2020 Newsletter
  • COVID-19 Information
    • Supporting Your Health and Well-being
    • Engaging with Nature at Home
  • Recent Research
    • ​Students & Staff Reading Recent Research Blog
  • Nature Near You
  • Current Projects
    • Education Working Group
    • Illinois NatureRx Working Group
  • Get Involved